The order of a feed is already a choice

Nothing disappears, yet the starting point changes. A fictional noticeboard makes the choices behind three orders visible.

Digital anthropology
Six sheets with blue and terracotta marks form a fan: the first is fully visible, while the others remain present but partly covered.
Being in the collection and being in the foreground are different conditions. AI-generated illustration: a metaphor for position, not a reproduction of a real feed.

A tram diversion has four reactions. A photograph of restored books has a hundred and twenty-six. If we sort the six messages prepared for this page by popularity, the photograph comes first and the diversion last. Not a sentence has been deleted. Yet for someone trying to reach a stop, the result may be of little use.

These are invented messages, with equally invented times and numbers. Their small imbalance keeps a question open: what are we rewarding when we decide what comes first?

Six messages, three ways in

For this note I have built a small fictional noticeboard, divided between a library and transport. It contains two photographs described in words and four notices. The texts, topics, times and reactions remain identical in all three versions; only the sequence changes. The letters A to F let us follow the same message as it moves.

Chronological order starts with the most recent. Topic order collects the library messages first, then transport, with the most recent first within each group. Popularity here means only the number of reactions assigned to each entry, from highest to lowest. There are no personal profiles, predictions or recommendations brought in from elsewhere.

The same noticeboard, three orders

Six fictional messages. Times, news and reactions are invented. The controls change only the order; no real platform is reproduced.

Without JavaScript, the three orders are available below, each with all six messages. The first three positions also make the partial comparison readable.

Most recent

From 09:25 to 09:00: the most recent message comes first.

  1. F · 09:25 · Transport · 4 reactions

    Tram diverted near the library

    Today the tram skips the Library stop. The alternative stop is in the square.

  2. E · 09:20 · Library · 9 reactions

    The library closes early today

    Today’s closing time is brought forward to 17:00 for maintenance.

  3. D · 09:15 · Transport · 32 reactions

    Travel pass renewals

    From Monday, passes can be renewed at the counter in the square.

  4. C · 09:10 · Library · 18 reactions

    The reading room reopens

    From tomorrow, the room on the first floor is available again.

  5. B · 09:05 · Transport · 84 reactions

    A tram from many years ago

    A photograph described in words: an old tram crosses the square.

  6. A · 09:00 · Library · 126 reactions

    The books after restoration

    A photograph described in words: three repaired volumes return to the shelf.

By topic

Library before Transport; most recent messages first within each group.

  1. E · 09:20 · Library · 9 reactions

    The library closes early today

    Today’s closing time is brought forward to 17:00 for maintenance.

  2. C · 09:10 · Library · 18 reactions

    The reading room reopens

    From tomorrow, the room on the first floor is available again.

  3. A · 09:00 · Library · 126 reactions

    The books after restoration

    A photograph described in words: three repaired volumes return to the shelf.

  4. F · 09:25 · Transport · 4 reactions

    Tram diverted near the library

    Today the tram skips the Library stop. The alternative stop is in the square.

  5. D · 09:15 · Transport · 32 reactions

    Travel pass renewals

    From Monday, passes can be renewed at the counter in the square.

  6. B · 09:05 · Transport · 84 reactions

    A tram from many years ago

    A photograph described in words: an old tram crosses the square.

Most reactions

From highest to lowest count: invented, fixed reactions.

  1. A · 09:00 · Library · 126 reactions

    The books after restoration

    A photograph described in words: three repaired volumes return to the shelf.

  2. B · 09:05 · Transport · 84 reactions

    A tram from many years ago

    A photograph described in words: an old tram crosses the square.

  3. D · 09:15 · Transport · 32 reactions

    Travel pass renewals

    From Monday, passes can be renewed at the counter in the square.

  4. C · 09:10 · Library · 18 reactions

    The reading room reopens

    From tomorrow, the room on the first floor is available again.

  5. E · 09:20 · Library · 9 reactions

    The library closes early today

    Today’s closing time is brought forward to 17:00 for maintenance.

  6. F · 09:25 · Transport · 4 reactions

    Tram diverted near the library

    Today the tram skips the Library stop. The alternative stop is in the square.

The first version opens with a tram diversion, the second with a change in library opening hours, the third with the restored books. If we stop at the first three entries, we also encounter three different selections. In the complete list we can reach the others by continuing; when we enable ‘First three entries’, however, they are hidden until we clear the checkbox.

That is the limited scope of the demonstration. We can check what occupies the first positions; knowing how much those positions change readers’ beliefs or behaviour would require different research. Nobody’s attention has been measured here.

The criterion carries a question

Sorting by most recent answers ‘what happened next?’ well. If we are following an update, that may be exactly what we need. But a notice from yesterday that still applies can end up behind many new entries less useful for our purpose. Time, too, becomes a priority when we give it the first position.

Grouping by topic brings together messages that time had separated. In the fictional library, the change in hours is read alongside the reopening of the reading room and the photograph of the restoration. A small context emerges. To build it, though, we had to assign a topic to each entry and decide which group to put first. ‘Library before transport’ is a decision in this demonstration that we could reverse.

With reactions, the question changes again: ‘what has already received more responses?’ The two photographs move up. Their numbers are easy to compare, while the usefulness of a diversion also depends on where we need to go. A precise criterion can give a precise answer to the wrong question.

On the left, sheets are grouped by similar motifs, blue circles and terracotta bars; on the right, a row runs from many black dots to few.
Grouping by similarity and ordering by quantity bring out different relationships. AI-generated conceptual illustration; the shapes and dots do not represent the six messages or their data.

This does not make popularity useless. It can help us find a conversation with many participants, as long as its number is not taken as a complete measure of its importance. On our noticeboard, reactions are fixed data: nobody can add any, and position does not change the count. We have not simulated the much more complex relationship between what is shown and what receives a response.

What remains after the third entry

To see the difference, imagine a pause. We open a list, read three messages, then have to do something else. With popularity order, the diversion does not enter that brief reading. With chronological order, it is the starting point. Its presence in the collection does not guarantee that we will encounter it at the same moment.

Making all the content available leaves the question of precedence open. Saying ‘that is there too, just scroll’ describes a real possibility; it still leaves the reader to find the time and do the work needed to reach it. How many messages each person reads remains a variable, not a property the list has resolved.

A paper strip with different motifs passes behind a blue frame that shows a short section; the rest of the strip continues across the desk.
The frame isolates a section while the sequence continues. AI-generated illustration: a metaphor for partial reading, without measurements of attention or deleted content.

In the demonstration, ‘First three entries’ makes this interruption explicit. It is a limit chosen for the comparison, the same in every version; it does not correspond to a psychological threshold. Clearing the checkbox shows where the others had gone. Even this small gesture helps separate two questions that we tend to merge: what does the noticeboard contain, and where does it invite us to start?

A rule that can be changed

Real systems can intervene at both levels. In the explanation published by Meta in 2023, ranking combines predictions, including whether a piece of content will be shared, and also concerns recommendations from accounts not followed. This is the company’s description, useful for distinguishing that system from our fixed count; it does not let us reconstruct an individual user’s actual sequence.

Another possibility emerges from Bluesky’s 2023 introduction to custom feeds: readers can choose between feeds also built by external developers. What interests me is the possibility of replacing the rule by which we start reading. The document does not show that every feed is transparent, or that being able to choose makes every option easy to understand.

In designing this page, I could set out the entire criterion in a few lines. We know which messages exist, how they are ordered and what changes when we press a control. A platform with selection and predictions requires much broader explanations. The demonstration’s simplicity isolates a choice we can observe, without turning it into an explanation of everything else.

I return to the tram diversion. When it falls to last place, it remains true within our fiction, and it remains available to read. If I opened the noticeboard to find out how to get to the library, I would need to encounter it sooner. The question to bring into the design is this: what need does the order we have left as the default answer?

On the left, sheets are grouped by similar motifs, blue circles and terracotta bars; on the right, a row runs from many black dots to few.
Grouping by similarity and ordering by quantity bring out different relationships. AI-generated conceptual illustration; the shapes and dots do not represent the six messages or their data.